top of page

Peanut Butter
Tomato and Onion Sandwich 

Revel in a tasty twist with our mouthwatering toasted sandwich featuring creamy peanut butter, rich mayo, juicy tomatoes, and savory onions—a playful fusion of flavors! This special tradition, passed down from my Tulsa-based grandparents, turns summer visits into cherished memories filled with these unique sandwiches. Embrace the joy of these childhood favorites that turned onion aversion into a flavorful adventure. Explore our sandwich ideas for enjoyable and fulfilling lunches!

Peanut Butter Onion and tomato Sandwich

Don’t forget to check out my Instagram account  – Or give me a follow on Facebook or see what I am pinning on Pinterest or Twitter!


As an Walmart Creator I earn from qualifying purchases.

Thank you so much
for supporting my  site!

How To Make Peanut Butter, Tomato and Onion Sandwich

Prepare Your Bread:

  • Lay out the two slices of bread and place them in a toaster. Toast them until they reach your desired level of crispiness.

Spread Peanut Butter:

  • Take one slice of the toasted bread and spread a generous layer of peanut butter evenly across it. Adjust the amount to suit your taste preferences.

Optional Mayo Spread:

  • If you choose to use mayonnaise salad dressing, spread it on the second slice of toasted bread evenly.

Layer with Tomato and Onion:

  • Place the thinly sliced tomatoes on the peanut butter-covered slice of toasted bread. Sprinkle a pinch of salt and pepper over the tomato slices.

Add Sliced Onion:

  • Now, add the thinly sliced onions on top of the tomatoes.

Bring It Together:

  • Carefully place the second slice of toasted bread (with or without mayo) on top of the onion layer, creating a sandwich. Press down gently to help the ingredients adhere.


Cut and Serve:

  • If you prefer, you can cut the sandwich diagonally to make two triangular halves. This step is optional but can make the sandwich easier to handle and eat.


  • Your Toasted Peanut Butter, Onion and Tomato Sandwich is ready to enjoy. The toasting process adds an extra layer of crunch and warmth to this unique sandwich, enhancing the flavors of the creamy peanut butter, juicy tomatoes, and crisp onions. It's a delightful blend of sweet, savory, and crunchy elements. Enjoy your homemade creation!


Feel free to customize the toasting time to achieve your desired level of toastiness, and remember to store any unused tomato and onion slices for future use.

Thank you so much
for supporting my  site!

Peanut Butter, Onion and Tomato Sandwich Tips

     Fresh garden tomatoes truly shine! This sandwich is a perfect choice for a delightful summer meal and an excellent method to make use of the surplus tomatoes. It's not only a nutritious option but also a hit with children; I've been savoring these since I was just four years old, all thanks to Grandma and her tale of Grandpa's tireless work in the garden! Each bite feels like a taste of heaven on a plate. In our youthful enthusiasm, my sibling and I used to devour two full sandwiches each, leaving Grandma pleasantly surprised by our hearty appetites; she always referred to us as "good eaters!"

    These sandwiches were simply outstanding in every way! The enduring love for Depression-era recipes is a testament to the resilience and ingenuity of generations past. These vintage, budget-friendly creations, born out of necessity during tough economic times, have a timeless appeal that transcends eras. Many cherish the simplicity and resourcefulness of these meals, finding comfort in their humble origins.

    Depression-era recipes like the peanut butter and tomato sandwich, made with accessible ingredients, embody the spirit of thriftiness in the kitchen. They serve as a reminder of how even in the face of scarcity, creativity can lead to culinary delights. These recipes are a culinary link to our history, a way to honor the past, and a source of inspiration for economical and delicious meals today.

Thank you so much
for supporting my  site!

There are numerous variations you can explore to customize your sandwich. Here are some unique sandwich ideas to inspire you:

  1. Peanut Butter and Banana: Spread peanut butter on one slice of bread and add slices of ripe banana. Optionally, you can drizzle honey for extra sweetness.

  2. Peanut Butter and Jelly: A classic combination. Spread peanut butter on one slice, and your favorite fruit jelly or jam on the other.

  3. Peanut Butter and Nutella: Combine the rich, nutty flavor of peanut butter with the creamy chocolate-hazelnut goodness of Nutella for a sweet and indulgent twist.

  4. Peanut Butter and Apple: Layer thin apple slices on top of peanut butter. Sprinkle with a touch of cinnamon for an extra kick.

  5. Peanut Butter and Honey: Drizzle honey over the peanut butter for a simple yet delicious sweet sandwich.

  6. Peanut Butter and Bacon: Add crispy bacon strips to your peanut butter sandwich for a sweet and savory contrast.

  7. Peanut Butter and Pickles: Surprisingly tasty, the crispness of pickles complements the creaminess of peanut butter. Try it with dill pickles.

  8. Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chips: Spread peanut butter on one slice and sprinkle mini chocolate chips for a delightful sweet treat.

  9. Peanut Butter and Marshmallow Fluff: For a gooey, sweet sensation, combine peanut butter with marshmallow fluff.

  10. Peanut Butter and Greek Yogurt: Spread Greek yogurt on one slice and add a drizzle of honey. This adds creaminess and a tangy flavor.

  11. Peanut Butter and Berries: Layer your peanut butter with fresh berries like strawberries, raspberries, or blueberries for a fruity twist.

  12. Peanut Butter and Nut Mix: Add some texture by mixing peanut butter with crushed nuts like almonds, walnuts, or pecans.

  13. Peanut Butter and Chia Jam: Instead of traditional jelly, use homemade chia jam for a healthier, fruity alternative.

  14. Peanut Butter and Avocado: Combine the creaminess of peanut butter with slices of ripe avocado for a unique and nutritious sandwich.

  15. Peanut Butter and Sriracha: If you like a spicy kick, add a touch of Sriracha sauce to your peanut butter for some heat.

Remember, the possibilities are virtually endless, so feel free to mix and match these ideas or invent your own unique peanut butter sandwich creations.

Please leave a comment if you have tried this recipe. All feedback helps improve our site.

Join Us
for the latest updates:




bottom of page